vor 2 Jahren

Issue 06/2017

  • Text
  • Bioplastics
  • Biobased
  • Materials
  • Products
  • Plastics
  • Packaging
  • Biodegradable
  • Sustainable
  • Compostable
  • Renewable

Opinion Position Paper:

Opinion Position Paper: Plastic bags Background What do lettuce from the weekly market, a pack of headache pills, a DVD, a teddy bear and jeans have in common? At first glance, you would think: nothing. But a second look reveals: often when you buy them, all these items are put in a disposable polymer bag, better known as plastic bag. Statistically, 45 plastic bags per capita were used in Germany in 2016 [1]. In a city like Oberhausen with 210,000 citizens this amounts to a total of almost 10 million bags per year. While some of the plastic bags are reused several times after their initial use, for example as a means of transport or as a garbage bag, most of them directly end up in the mixed waste bin or, as it should be, are fed into recycling via the yellow bin, the German lightweight packaging collecting system. Especially so called hygiene bags with a wall thickness of less than 15 μm (0.015 mm), often used for fruit and vegetables bought at markets and grocery stores, are just used once. The amount of plastic litter in the oceans is still increasing – in total it is estimated to be 27-66,7 million tonnes [2] – and more and more pictures of starved birds and beached whales with their stomachs full of plastics fragments and bags instead of food are going around the world [3]. That is why plastics, especially in the form of plastic bags and packaging, are increasingly becoming a subject of harsh criticism. For many years, plastic bags have been one of the top 10 litter items found during beach clean-ups [4]. Several initiatives, like plastic-free shops [5] or plastic-free cities [6], aim at completely abandoning these products. In April 2016 the Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature conservation, Construction and Nuclear Safety (BMUB) and the Trade Association of Germany (HDE) signed a voluntary agreement to reduce the use of plastic bags by half in the next ten years. Therein, the participating companies commit themselves to charge their customers a reasonable fee for plastic bags from 1 July 2016 at the latest. Exceptions are only made for very light carrier bags with a wall thickness below 15 μm (i. e. hygiene bags) and freezer and long-life carrier bags with a wall thickness of more than 50 μm. The latter types had already mostly been charged for anyway. Many retailers have reacted and do not offer free bags anymore but charge a fee for plastic bags instead. Some even go a step further. The German food retailer REWE, for example, has completely stopped the sale of plastic bags since 1 June 2016 and nowadays offers alternatives made from cotton, jute or paper as well as reusable bags from recycled materials or cardboard boxes [7]. In September 2016 the German discounter Lidl also announced not to offer standard plastic bags any more starting in 2017 [8]. Today, one can find long-life carrier bags, cotton and paper bags as eco-friendly alternatives in their stores [9]. 52 bioplastics MAGAZINE [06/17] Vol. 12

Opinion By: Jürgen Bertling, Stephan Kabasci Markus Hiebel, Leandra Harmann Fraunhofer UMSICHT Oberhausen, Germany But how should the subject be evaluated from a scientific perspective? Experts from Fraunhofer UMSICHT have compiled the following facts and assessments. Position of Fraunhofer UMSICHT 1. Similar to the criticized material polyvinyl chloride (PVC) the plastic bag has become a highly symbolic icon in environmental debates. It has been singled out from a variety of plastic products which have quite a similar relevance from an environmental perspective. Its importance regarding the quantitative environmental impact is frequently overrated and the complexity of the overall problem with polymers in the environment tends to be oversimplified. This makes an unbiased discussion based on facts difficult. 2. The mass fraction of plastic bags accounts for less than one percent of the total consumption of plastics. With 45 per capita and year the consumption of plastic bags in Germany is well below the EU average of 198 bags per capita and year. Nevertheless, there are countries such as Luxembourg and Ireland which show a significantly lower consumption [1, 10]. 3. Life cycle assessments (LCA) do not show specific advantages of paper and cotton bags over bags made from conventional plastics or bio-plastics. A multiple use of bags has positive effects on LCA results [11]. However, LCAs are quite limited in their informative value. For example, long term necessary paradigm shifts (from fossil to renewable sources), the technical level of development of materials or products (learning curve of efficiency) or the impact of litter – including microplastics – in the environment are not or not sufficiently considered yet. 4. The utilization of biodegradable materials as alternative sources for plastic bags needs further investigation. It is known that not all biodegradable plastics degrade as quickly in different environmental compartments (e.g. on and in the soil, in fresh and sea water) as it is proven in standard laboratory tests. However, even a slower degradation – albeit lasting several years – would already improve the situation compared to the extremely long lasting standard plastics bags (mostly made out of the polyolefines PE or PP). Closer examinations of degradation mechanisms and kinetics in the environment as well as sociological studies dealing with the suspected rebound effect of increased littering of biodegradable bags into the environment are yet to be carried out. 5. Plastic bags made of polyethylene (PE) with catalytic additives which enhance oxidative fragmentation (so called oxo-degradables) are to be strictly rejected. They purposefully produce microplastics which can have severe consequences in the low trophic levels (plankton, bivalves, worms etc.) of the food chain (please see our position paper on microplastics for further information) [12]. 450- 400- 350- 300- 250- 200- 150- 100- 50- Number of plastic bags used per capita in 2010 in the EU [13] 0- Bulgaria - 421 Czech Rep. -297 Greece - 269 Romania - 252 Italy - 204 EU 27 - 198 Cyprus - 140 UK - 137 Spain - 133 Malta - 119 Sweden - 111 Belgium - 98 Netherlands - 81 France - 79 Denmark - 79 Finland - 77 Germany - 71 Austria - 51 Luxembourg - 20 Ireland - 18 bioplastics MAGAZINE [06/17] Vol. 12 53

bioplastics MAGAZINE ePaper